Thursday 29 August 2013

Majority Rule v Good Governance

Good governance requires democracy; but our shire are strong on rhetoric but poor on democratic performance. A majority vote is not enough for our democratic rights to be served. The topic is covered better in the The Report of the Inquiry into the City of Joondalup than I could do here.
Chapter 2 is especially entertaining and can certainly be seen to reflect the performance of the current Council.
When residents read that ex-Cr McGregor and Cr Serventy are regularly told to close down discussion and debate, and that “closed door” meetings have become the normal way of decision making, then obviously something is not democratic in this shire.
Democracy requires open debate and deliberation that the public can understand. Communication with councillors must be two way process. Until we have that we will continue to be concerned that our democratic rights are being eroded, whether we gossip together, write letters, send emails, post on social media, twitter or tweet we will communicate.

The shire can ignore the community but they would be far better advised to engage in e-democracy and begin to use mediated communication to better understand the people that they are paid to serve. Germany has embraced e-democracy fully and wholeheartedly, Greece did not.

3 comments:

Heather said...

There are some examples of Australia using e-democracy;
www.egov.vic.gov.au/trends-and-issues/e-democracy.html

Anonymous said...

Hi Heather, this is a key issue in the local government we have ... but it does not need to be this way - I went to a Planning Committee meeting at Armadale in 2000 that was a revelation. Can you please point us to the relevant section of the Joondalup Report?
Thanks, Linton

Heather said...

The whole of Chapter 2 is worth reading, but the section from the transcript in para 25 on page 2-7 onward gives a good general explanation of the difference between majority rule and good governance. If you click on the The Report of the Inquiry into the City of Joondalup the whole report should download.
If you, or anyone else reading this, wish to post on this blog then please send me your email, to progress@karridale.com, and I will include you on the list of authors. That way you can choose entirely new directions of enquiry, comment and observation.
Cheers

Post a Comment